Matchups to Watch: VT vs. NC State
by Phil Martin, 9/2/05
In many football games, key match-ups may dictate the eventual winner.
Winning critical match-ups in the trenches can often have a profound impact on
the outcome of a game. Mismatches between the wide receivers and the secondary
frequently lead to big plays that may determine the ultimate winner. Teams that
win the critical individual battles as well as exploit or compensate for
mismatches in personnel will generally be victorious.
In this article I will focus on the key match-ups of the Virginia Tech at
N.C. State game and hopefully give fans some critical aspects of the game to
watch closely on Sunday. In essence, this article will attempt to provide a
glimpse of the �game within the game� that makes football such a fascinating
sport.
Living on the Edge � Offensive Tackles vs. Defensive Ends
N.C. State and Virginia Tech are two of the best, if not the best, edge
rushing teams in the nation. Both teams have defenses predicated on providing
pressure, particularly from the defensive ends. The ability of either team to
neutralize the other�s edge rushers could be the single most critical factor
in winning the game on Sunday. Both teams will likely use multiple techniques to
slow down the edge rush, including chipping on the defensive ends with tight
ends and backs. Chipping, for those unfamiliar with the term, is a technique in
which a player, such as a tight end, puts a shoulder into the defensive end at
the line-of-scrimmage to prevent the rusher from getting a quick first step,
before continuing on to his pass route or blocking assignment.
In addition to blocking techniques, teams will often call certain plays to
neutralize the aggressiveness of the pass rush off the edge. Virginia Tech will
likely run the option which forces the defensive ends to �read and react�
rather than aggressively pursue the ball. N.C. State, and to a lesser extent
Virginia Tech, likes to call screens and quick flare passes to the backs to
allow rushing defensive ends to take themselves out of the play. Both teams will
try to run directly at the speed rushers to neutralize their quickness. Much of
the play-calling in this game will be dictated by the need to neutralize the
rush off the edge.
However, no matter what strategies are used by the respective coaches,
ultimately the players themselves determine who wins the battle on the edge.
Here is a quick look at the intriguing match-ups between the offensive tackles
and defensive ends in this game.
OT
Duane Brown
#76, 6-5, 292, r-So. |
DE
Mario Williams
#9, 6-7, 290, Jr. |
Easily the most analyzed match-up in this game, right tackle Duane Brown
(6-5, 292, r-So.) vs. left defensive end Mario Williams (6-7, 290, Jr.) is a
heavyweight battle between two potential first-round NFL draft choices. Williams
will certainly be coming out early for the NFL draft next year and will likely
be one of the first three players chosen based on current projections. He has
all of the physical tools with great size, strength (benches 435 pounds), and
speed (runs a 4.6 40) as well as an aggressive attitude. His statistics (6
sacks, 15 tackles for loss) may not seem overwhelming, but every team has to
game plan around him and Virginia Tech will be no exception.
Obviously, Duane Brown is inexperienced at offensive tackle, having just been
moved from tight end to right tackle a couple of weeks ago, and will have his
hands full with �Super Mario.� Williams will certainly show him a variety of
moves to take advantage of his inexperience and Brown will have to adapt quickly
in the game. However, Brown has exceptional footwork and is familiar with many
of the techniques used by offensive tackles from practicing with the same group,
so this inexperience may not be as substantial as the casual fan may think. Tech
will likely use tight ends to help out, but ultimately Brown needs to hold his
own against Williams to give Marcus Vick time to throw. This match-up in the
trenches may be the most interesting battle to watch all year for Virginia Tech.
DE
Darryl Tapp
#58, 6-1, 268, Sr. |
OT
James Newby
#78, 6-5, 295, r-Jr. |
While many may feel that Duane Brown vs. Mario Williams is the game�s
biggest mismatch, I would argue that left tackle James Newby (6-5, 295, r-Jr.)
vs. weak-side defensive end Darryl Tapp (6-1, 268, Sr.) is potentially the most
one-sided battle of the edge rushers in this game. Tapp is a relentless
competitor with exceptional physical skills (415 bench, 660 squat, 370 push
press, 4.63 40) developed through hard work in the weight room. Darryl Tapp is
probably one of the top three defensive ends in college football (along with
Mario Williams and BC�s Mathias Kiwanuka) and presents a huge challenge for
the N.C. State coaching staff. Newby is a versatile player that started some at
left guard (3 games) and right tackle (3 games) last year. He is considered a
good technician who is noted more for being a pass blocker, however, he lacks
lateral quickness and could struggle against Tapp�s speed rush. Look for N.C.
State to provide help for Newby from their backs and to call quick screens and
flares to the weak side to offset Tapp�s pass rush.
OT
Jimmy Martin
#52, 6-5, 311, Sr. |
DE
Manny Lawson
#91, 6-5, 245, Sr. |
In a classic power vs. speed match-up, left tackle Jimmy Martin (6-5, 311,
Sr.) takes on right defensive end Manny Lawson (6-5, 245, Sr.). Lawson�s edge
rush gave Martin problems last year and I�m sure that Jimmy has been looking
forward to getting revenge this year. Lawson has incredible speed (recently
timed at 4.43 in the 40) and athleticism (won the ACC indoor long jump
championship) for a player his size. In previous years he made numerous plays in
space (7 sacks, 17 QB hurries last year), but struggled when blockers got their
hands on him. He has gained 25 pounds in the off-season conditioning program and
should be stronger at the point of attack this year.
However, Jimmy Martin has exceptional hand strength and power (410 bench, 600
squat, 390 push press, 360 clean) and should consistently win this battle
head-to-head. Martin needs to be quick laterally to neutralize Lawson�s
incredible edge rush and push him beyond the quarterback. Look for Tech to use
shorter drops (3-step and 5-step) and quicker passes from Marcus Vick to offset
the edge rush and blitzes from N.C. State. Also, look for Tech to run directly
at Manny Lawson, particularly when the Hokies have the ball on the right hash
mark. N.C. State�s strong-side linebacker, LeRue Rumph (#29), is more of a
pass defender than their weak-side linebacker, Stephen Tulloch (#50), who is
very strong in run support, and Tech needs to take advantage of situations in
which Lawson and Rumph line up on the same side of the field.
DE
Chris Ellis
#49, 6-5, 250, r-So.
DE Noland Burchette
#96, 6-2, 260, r-Jr. |
OT
Derek Morris
#71, 6-6, 327, Jr. |
Yet another power vs. speed match-up pits huge right tackle Derek Morris
(6-6, 327, Jr.) against Tech�s stud (strong-side) defensive ends, Chris Ellis
(6-5, 250, r-So.) and Noland Burchette (6-2, 260, r-Jr.). Morris was a
highly-touted recruit who originally signed with Ohio State. After some
qualification issues, he transferred to N.C. State and immediately saw action at
left tackle. Last year he started at right tackle, which is his more natural
position. Morris has awesome strength (benches 500 pounds) and has lost over 30
pounds since arriving as a freshman through diligent work in the off-season
conditioning program. Morris should be much more effective run blocking with the
increased agility and he is a good pass blocker once he locks onto the rusher,
but he has struggled against speed rushers off the edge.
Tech�s stud ends, and Chris Ellis in particular, are exceptional edge
rushers, so it will be interesting to see if Morris will have enough lateral
quickness to handle them. Ellis is exceptionally fast (4.62 40) with a quick
first step and Burchette is one of the quickest players off the line on Tech�s
team (1.50 10-yard dash) with very good speed (4.69 40). Look for N.C. State to
run behind Morris in short-yardage situations. Morris is said to be greatly
improved and he should be one of the better offensive tackles in the ACC this
year.
All four of the offensive tackle vs. defensive end match-ups should be very
interesting to follow in this game.
Playing the Slots � Receivers vs. Strong Safeties
Both Virginia Tech and N.C. State are starting new strong safeties (rover in
Tech�s terminology) that are reputed to be strong in run support but weaker in
space against the pass. Both teams like to use three-receiver formations with
the slot receiver on the wide side of the field, so look for similar strategies
in trying exploit the inexperience of the strong safeties. However, the approach
each team uses may be different. Tech may look to go deep more while N.C. State
will look to throw in front of Tech�s rover.
ROV
Aaron Rouse
#36, 6-4, 221, r-Jr. |
WR
Tramain Hall
#21, 5-10, 194, r-Sr. |
Tramain Hall (5-10, 194, r-Sr.) is a preseason first-team all-ACC wide
receiver who will generally be matched up with Aaron Rouse (6-4, 221, r-Jr.), a
converted whip linebacker in his first year at rover. Hall is a former all-star
running back in high school who was converted to slot receiver in State�s
offense. He lines up in various positions, but generally will go to the wide
side of the field. Hall has great hands with excellent ability to gain yards
after the catch. Two years ago he caught 69 passes from Philip Rivers, though
that number dropped to 28 last year due to injuries and a new quarterback. Hall
generally runs shorter routes, but he will occasionally go deep on wheel routes.
N.C. State will surely challenge Rouse, who is an exceptional athlete with
outstanding speed (4.44 40) but has never played a game at the position. The
biggest question regarding Rouse is his ability to provide coverage in space,
and Tramain Hall will definitely test that concern. In the last couple of years
Tech has played more zone coverage and I look for the Hokies to mix their
coverages in this game, bracketing Hall underneath in two-deep and three-deep
zones. When in man-to-man coverage, Rouse must play Hall physically and try to
disrupt his routes. Tech handled Hall well last year and this match-up is
probably the key receiving concern for the Hokies on Sunday.
WR
David Clowney
#87, 6-1, 175, Jr. |
SS
Garland Heath
#19, 6-2, 225, Jr. |
Unlike Aaron Rouse, Garland Heath (6-2, 225, Jr.) has played strong safety in
his previous two years (171 plays as a true freshman and 71 plays last year) and
gained a reputation for being very strong in run support. He is adequate in pass
coverage but lacks recovery speed (estimated 40 in the 4.6-4.7 range) against
the deep ball. Tech will play a number of different receivers in the slot, but I
believe that the Hokies will try to isolate one of their speed receivers, such
as David Clowney (6-1, 175, Jr., 4.33 40), on Heath and see if Vick can connect
on a big play.
The Big Pass-Catchers - Tight Ends vs. Strong Safeties
TE
Jeff King
#90, 6-5, 253, r-Sr. |
SS Garland Heath
#19, 6-2, 225, Jr.
|
ROV
Cary Wade
#30, 5-10, 178, r-Jr. |
TE
T.J. Williams
#80, 6-4, 253, Sr. |
Both teams also have very good receiving tight ends in first-team preseason
all-ACC Jeff King (6-5, 253, r-Sr.) for Tech and two-time honorable mention
all-ACC T.J. Williams (6-3, 253, Sr.) for N.C. State. King has exceptional
hands and runs good routes with improved agility from playing basketball last
year. He will occasionally be matched up against the strong safety, Garland
Heath, in this game and Tech may try to get King behind the secondary for a
big play at some time. T.J. Williams may be the most underrated player on
State�s team. He has excellent speed (estimated 4.7-4.8 40 range) for a
tight end and is one of the strongest players on the team. Williams led N.C.
State in receiving last year with 31 receptions and should see even more
action in the new west coast offense. State may try to exploit the size
mismatch when Cary Wade (5-10, 178, r-Jr.) is substituting for Aaron Rouse and
hit Williams down the field.
Vertical Limit � Quarterbacks vs. Free Safeties
QB
Marcus Vick
#5, 6-0, 216, r-Jr. |
FS Miguel Scott
#25, 6-0, 203, So.
|
FS
DJ Parker
#25, 6-0, 184, So.
FS Justin Hamilton
#27, 6-3, 230, r-Sr. |
QB Jay Davis
#10, 6-2, 220, r-Sr.
|
Obviously, all eyes will be on Marcus Vick (6-0, 216, r-Jr.) in his debut
as a starter and his ability to remain poised and create big plays will be
critical for Tech to win the game on Sunday. From the N.C. State perspective,
all eyes will be on Jay Davis (6-2, 220, r-Sr.) and his ability to run the
newly-installed west coast offense. However, new �quarterbacks� of the
secondary will be playing for each team as well. D.J. Parker (6-0, 184, So.)
will get his first start at free safety for Tech and Miguel Scott (6-0, 203,
So.) gets the starting call for N.C. State. Both free safeties are excellent
athletes with good coverage skills but they each have limited playing
experience and potentially could be exploited for big plays.
With both teams having such strong defenses up front, driving the ball
downfield consistently will be difficult, so ultimately the team that can
create the big plays will likely win. Both teams may look to take advantage of
the inexperience at safety to hit the big play on deep posts or go routes. In
throwing the deep ball, Marcus Vick holds a big advantage over Jay Davis whose
deep ball tends to hang. Also, Tech has considerably more speed at wide
receiver than State, so the potential for hitting the �home run� would
appear to be to the Hokies advantage. N.C. State�s fastest receiver is
Lamart Barrett (6-1 190, Jr.), who runs a 4.45 40, whereas Tech has four
receivers that run faster than that time: David Clowney, Justin Harper (6-3
210, So., 4.36), Eddie Royal (5-10 171, So., 4.39), and Josh Hyman (6-0 189,
r-So., 4.41). N.C. State has very good receivers with excellent size and
experience (3 of the top 4 receivers are seniors), but they lack a deep
threat.
In a game that appears to be evenly matched in the trenches with both
defenses looking dominant, the ability to make big plays � whether in the
passing game, on special teams, or turnovers � will ultimately decide the
outcome. Tech appears to have more big-play potential than N.C. State, so I
see the Hokies being victorious in a game that may be similar to the Georgia
Tech game from last year. Big plays in the fourth quarter will likely
determine the winner.
Prediction: Virginia Tech 23, N.C. State 13
TSL Pass Home
TSL Home
|